Subtrochanteric Fractures

Topic updated on 04/14/15 8:52pm
  • Subtrochanteric typically defined as area from lesser trochanter to 5cm distal
    • fractures with an associated intertrochanteric component may be called
      • intertrochanteric fracture with subtrochanteric extension
      • peritrochanteric fracture
  • Epidemiology
    • usually in younger patients with a high-energy mechanism
    • may occur in elderly patients from a low-energy mechanism 
      • rule out pathologic or atypical femur fracture  
        • bisphosphonate use, particularly alendronate, can be risk factor 
  • Pathoanatomy
    • deforming forces on the proximal fragment are     
      • abduction
        • gluteus medius   and gluteus minimus 
      • flexion
        • iliopsoas 
      • external rotation
        • short external rotators 
    • deforming forces on distal fragment
      • adduction & shortening
        • adductors 
  • Biomechanics
    • weight bearing leads to net compressive forces on medial cortex and tensile forces on lateral cortex
Russel-Taylor Classification
Type I No extension into piriformis fossa
Type II Extension into greater trochanter with involvement of piriformis fossa
 •  look on lateral xray to identify piriformis fossa extension
 • Historically used to differentiate between fractures that would amenable to an intramedullary nail (type I) and those that required some form of a lateral fixed angle device (type II)
 • Current interlocking options with both trochanteric and piriformis entry nails allow for treatment of type II fractures with intramedullary implants
AO/OTA Classification Examples
32-A3.1 Simple (A), Transverse (3), Subtrochanteric fracture (0.1)   
32-B3.1 Wedge (B), Fragmented (3), Subtrochanteric fracture (0.1)
32-C1.1 Complex (C), Spiral (1), Subtrochanteric fracture (0.1)
 Facture Location 
 • Femur (3) , Diaphysis (2), Subtrochanteric region (0.1)
Fracture Pattern
 •  Simple (A), Wedge (B), Complex (C)
  • Symptoms
    • hip and thigh pain
    • inability to bear weight
  • Physical exam
    • pain with motion
    • typically associated with obvious deformity (shortening and varus alignment)
    • flexion of proximal fragment may threaten overlying skin
  • Radiographs
    • required views
      • AP and lateral of the hip
      • AP pelvis
      • full length femur films including the knee
    • additional views
      • traction views may assist with defining fragments in comminuted patterns but is not required
    • findings
      • bisphosphonate-related fractures have 
        • lateral cortical thickening
        • transverse fracture orientation
        • medial spike
        • lack of comminution
  • Nonoperative
    • observation with pain management
      • indications
        • non-ambulatory patients with medical co-morbidities that would not allow them to tolerate surgery
        • limited role due to strong muscular forces displacing fracture and inability to mobilize patients without surgical intervention
  • Operative
    • intramedullary nailing (usually cephalomedullary) 
      • indications
        • historically Russel-Taylor type I fractures
        • newer design of intramedullary nails has expanded indications
        • most subtrochanteric fractures treated with IM nail 
    • fixed angle plate 
      • indications
        • surgeon preference
        • associated femoral neck fracture
        • narrow medullary canal
        • pre-existing femoral shaft deformity
  • Intramedullary Nailing
    • position
      • lateral positioning post
        • advantages 
          • allows for easier reduction of the distal fragment to the flexed proximal fragment 
          • allows for easier access to entry portal, especially for piriformis nail
      • supine positioning
        • advantages
          • protective to the injured spine
          • address other injuries in polytrauma patients
          • easier to assess rotation
    • techniques
      • 1st generation nail (rarely used)
      • 2nd generation reconstruction nail
      • cephalomedullary nail 
      • trochanteric or piriformis entry portal 
        • piriformis nail may mitigate risk of iatrogenic malreduction from proximal valgus bend of trochanteric entry nail  
    • pros
      • preserves vascularity
      • load-sharing implant
      • stronger construct in unstable fracture patterns
    • cons
      • reduction technically difficult 
        • nail can not be used to aid reduction 
        • fracture must be reduced prior to and during passage of nail
        • may require percutaneous reduction aids or open clamp placement to achieve and maintain reduction  
      • mismatch of the radius of curvature
        • nails with a larger radius of curvature (straighter) can lead to perforation of the anterior cortex of the distal femur 
    • complications
      • varus malreduction (see complications below)
  • Fixed angle plate 
    • approach  
      • lateral approach to proximal femur 
        • may split or elevate vastus lateralis off later intermuscular septum
        • dangers include perforating branches of profunda femoris
    • technique
      • 95 degree blade plate or condylar screw
      • sliding hip screw is contraindicated due to high rate of malunion and failure
      • blade plate may function as a tension band construct 
        • femur eccentrically loaded with tensile force on the lateral cortex converted to compressive force on medial cortex
    • cons
      • compromise vascularity of fragments
      • inferior strength in unstable fracture patterns
  • Varus/ procurvatum malunion 
    • the most frequent intraoperative complication with antegrade nailing of a subtrochanteric femur fracture is varus and procurvatum (or flexion) malreduction
  • Nonunion 
    • can be treated with plating
      • allows correction of varus malalignment
  • Bisphosphonate fractures  
    • nail fixation
      • increased risk of iatrogenic fracture
        • because of brittle bone and cortical thickening
      • increased risk of nonunion with nail fixation resulting in increased need for revision surgery
    • plate fixation
      • increased risk of plate hardware failure
        • because of varus collapse and dependence on intramembranous healing inhibited by bisphosphonates


Please Rate Educational Value!
Average 4.0 of 40 Ratings

Qbank (12 Questions)

(OBQ12.173) A 76-year-old female with underlying osteoporosis presents with severe right leg pain after stepping off a curb. Current femur radiographs are shown in Figure A. Review of the patient's medical records reveal that she had been evaluated 3 months prior for right hip pain, and work-up at that time was negative. Radiographs of the patient's femur from that previous visit are shown in Figure B. What is the most likely cause of this patient's femur fracture? Topic Review Topic
FIGURES: A   B        

1. Fibrous cortical defect
2. Metastatic lesion
3. Acute trauma
4. Bisphosphonate treatment
5. Osteomyelitis

(OBQ11.109) Which of the following fractures seen in Figures A through E would be amenable to fixation with a construct using tension band principles? Topic Review Topic
FIGURES: A   B   C   D   E  

1. Figure A
2. Figure B
3. Figure C
4. Figure D
5. Figure E

(OBQ11.137) An 80-year-old female falls and sustains the fracture seen in Figure A. She is treated with an antegrade cephalomedullary nail. Which of the following led to the complication seen in Figure B? Topic Review Topic
FIGURES: A   B        

1. Nail with a lesser radius of curvature
2. Nail with a greater radius of curvature
3. Piriformis entry portal
4. Trochanteric entry portal
5. Lateral decubitus patient position

(OBQ11.199) A 66-year-old male with a remote history of prostate cancer sustains a fall down a hill while gardening. During intramedullary nailing of his fracture, which intraoperative reduction maneuvers should take place to the proximal fragment to properly align the fracture? Topic Review Topic
FIGURES: A   B        

1. Flexion and internal rotation
2. Extension and internal rotation
3. Flexion and external rotation
4. Extension and external rotation
5. Abduction and internal rotation

(OBQ11.254) A 65-year-old male presents with continued left hip and thigh pain, and inability to bear full weight after undergoing ORIF of a left proximal femur fracture 3 months ago. Current radiographs are shown in Figure A. The patient denies any fevers, or other systemic signs of illness. Which of the following would have potentially decreased the risk of excess fracture collapse and implant failure in this patient? Topic Review Topic
FIGURES: A          

1. Use of a six-hole 135 degree compression plate
2. Addition of iliac crest autograft to the fracture site
3. Application of long strut allografts around the fracture site
4. Placement of a cephalomedullary nail
5. Addition of an 7.3mm de-rotation screw in the femoral head

(OBQ10.230) A 35-year-old-male sustains the fracture seen in Figure A. Which of the following reduction forces must be applied to the proximal fragment to correct the deformity commonly seen in these fractures? Topic Review Topic
FIGURES: A          

1. Adduction and extension
2. Abduction and extension
3. Adduction and flexion
4. Abduction and flexion
5. External rotation

(OBQ08.237) All of the following are advantages of supine over lateral positioning during intramedullary nailing of subtrochanteric femur fractures EXCEPT: Topic Review Topic

1. Can be protective to an injured spine
2. Facilitates access to other injured sites in the polytrauma patient
3. Provides easier fluoroscopic imaging
4. Allows for easy reduction of the distal fragment to the flexed proximal fragment
5. Easier to assess rotation

(OBQ05.148) Which muscles cause the fracture displacement of the proximal fragment shown in figure A? Topic Review Topic
FIGURES: A          

1. gluteus maximus and adductors
2. gluteus maximus and rectus femoris
3. gluteus medius and hamstrings
4. gluteus medius and iliopsoas
5. rectus femoris and hamstrings

(OBQ04.118) What muscles are responsible for the most common deformity after antegrade intramedullary nailing for a subtrochanteric femur fracture? Topic Review Topic

1. Hip abductors and iliopsoas muscle
2. Hip internal rotators and iliopsoas muscle
3. Quadriceps and iliopsoas muscle
4. Hamstring and iliopsoas muscle
5. Quadriceps and hip adductors

Sorry, this question is available to Virtual Curriculum members only.

Click HERE to learn more and purchase the Virtual Curriculum today!

HPI - Injury 18 months ago treated with DCS Patient has been walking for last year H...
185 responses
HPI - Elderly gentleman sustained a fracture of his left femur when he had fall from a...
68 responses
HPI - Had a tibial fracture on the other side
357 responses
HPI - Trauma. Bicyclist struck by car.
293 responses
HPI - Truck driver Fall getting out of truck Complex femoral shaft fracture 30 years...
4502 responses
HPI - Sub trochanteric fracture treated by long gamma nail 1 year ago. Patient lost...
poll How would you manage this case ?
363 responses
HPI - 55yo male with fall from height resulting in subtroch fracture. Treated with CMN...
poll How would you treat this initial fracture?
124 responses
HPI - Road traffic accident, fall from bike. no other injury. patient vitally and syst...
poll method of fixation? open or closed reduction? with or without bone grafti...
226 responses
HPI - Patient has a mechanic fall in Asia in April 2014. Treated with ORIF with proxim...
poll What is your preferred treatment for femoral subtrochanteric fractures?
758 responses
HPI - 90f frail, AAA, HTN with mechanical fall onto left hip. Isolated left hip pain.
poll What is your preferred treatment for reverse obliquity subtrochanteric prox...
1716 responses
HPI - Optd at a different center with DHS fixation for subtrochanteric fracture right...
poll What would be your fixation method of choice for the initial injury
200 responses
HPI - Operated for Comminuted Subtrochanteric fracture of right femur in Dec 2014 at d...
poll How would you have fixed the initial fracture.
2 responses
HPI - Subtrochanteric hip fracture treated 4 months ago at a peripheral hospital. Tran...
poll What would be your approach in the management of this fracture?
399 responses
HPI - MVA since 5 days with comminuted proximal femur , patient underwent fixation of...
poll Best way to fix the proximal fracture
165 responses
HPI - MVA 3 days ago - intact neurovascular state with moderate edema slight ecchymosi...
poll What is the best implant for such fracture
454 responses
HPI - Motor vehicle accident since 5 days with closed comminuted subtrochanteric fract...
poll What would be your preferred implant for this fracture
354 responses
HPI - Alleged Motorvehicle Accident (frontal collision between cars) Patient was sitt...
poll I am a medical student, i am still learning. This looks like a subtrochante...
93 responses
HPI - Sustained fracture after simple fall on the ground on her side
poll Best treatments possible ?
11 responses 3.jpg
HPI - motor vehicle accident.
poll how can i proceed
180 responses
HPI - Fall from a standing height 3 weeks ago , the patient denies to be operated
poll When is the best time to operate?
305 responses sub troch.jpg sub troch1.jpg post 3.jpg
HPI - fell of a cycle at hihg speed
poll nailing or plating
222 responses
HPI - s/p IM nailing at outside hospital after ATV rollover injury 4 months ago
poll How would you treat this?
566 responses (1).jpg
HPI - 3 months back h/o trauma hit by car. treated with 95 dhs. h/o unprotected weight...
poll what would be you treatment preference
268 responses xr -3.jpg
HPI - A 65-year diabetic female had fracture Rt. femur(subtrochanteric) before 4 yea...
poll how can manage this lady now
104 responses postop ap.jpg postop lateral.jpg postop ap distal.jpg
HPI - 87F community ambulator, left subtroch fracture treated with IM nail and cerclag...
poll How would you revise this case?
251 responses femur ao 31a2.jpg
HPI - fell into a drainage ditch
poll treatment
17 responses
HPI - Unable to bearweight with the right lower limb following fall injury. Pain and...
poll What is the best treatment option?
474 responses femur 6a.jpg femur 6b.jpg femur 6c.jpg
HPI - 30 y/o otherwise healthy male with left femur fracture. Presents ~45 min after...
poll What implant do you use for this fracture?
209 responses
poll what is the proper fix options?
15 responses
See More Cases


This surgical video demonstrates intramedullary nailing in lateral position with...
See More Videos



Topic Comments